An objection isn’t a no. It’s a business owner telling you what they need to hear before they say yes.
Anyone selling spots on a shared postcard hears the same dozen objections. The good news is that they’re predictable, so you can prepare honest answers in advance. This guide lists the postcard sales objections you’ll hear most, what’s usually behind each one, and how to answer without pressure.
First, a few ground rules
- Agree before you answer. “That’s fair” or “a lot of owners say that” lowers the temperature and earns you the right to reply.
- Ask a question back. Find out what’s really behind the objection before you answer it.
- Never promise results. You can share how the card works and what you’ll measure. You can’t guarantee calls, and saying so builds trust.
- Make the next step small. A smaller spot, a later campaign, or a look at the card layout is still a yes.
The objections and how to answer them
1. “It’s too expensive.”
Usually means: they don’t yet see what one customer is worth.
Try: “What’s a new customer worth to you over a year?” Then do the math together: if one job pays for the spot, the card only needs to bring one. Offer a smaller spot if the budget really is the issue. Our pricing guide shows how to explain cost per home.
2. “Does direct mail even work anymore?”
Usually means: they’ve been burned by advertising before.
Try: “It works best when people can act on it, and a postcard on the fridge stays there for weeks. Every ad gets its own QR code, so you’ll see exactly how many people scanned yours.” Measurement answers this objection better than any statistic.
3. “I tried postcards before and nothing happened.”
Usually means: the offer, the design or the area was wrong.
Try: “What did the card say, and where did it go?” Often the ad had no offer or went to the wrong neighborhood. Explain how you choose routes for their customers and help them write an offer people act on.
4. “I get enough business from word of mouth.”
Usually means: they’re busy now and don’t feel the need.
Try: “That’s a great problem. Is there a slow season, or a service you’d like more of?” Many busy trades still want more of their best-paying jobs, or work in the quiet months.
5. “I need to think about it.”
Usually means: a question they haven’t asked, or they need to check with someone.
Try: “Of course. What would you want to know before deciding?” Then give a real deadline: the booking deadline for this card, and that their category goes to the first business that books.
6. “My competitor will be on there too.”
Try: “Only one business per category, so if you book, you’re the only one.” If you run your cards that way, this objection becomes your best selling point.
7. “Send me some information.”
Usually means: a polite exit.
Try: “Happy to. I’ll send the link to this card’s page so you can see the spots, the area and what’s left.” A live sales page with the card and the open spots does more than a brochure, and you can follow up in two days.
8. “I don’t have an ad.”
Try: “No problem. You can pick a ready-made design for your industry, and I’ll fit your details in.” Taking the work off their plate removes the objection completely.
9. “I’ll wait and see how the first one goes.”
Try: “That makes sense. I’ll show you the scan results after this one mails. If you’d like, I can hold your category on the next card for a week once results are in.” Add them to the waitlist and follow up when the card lands.
10. “How do I know you’ll actually mail it?”
Usually means: they don’t know you yet.
Try: Show your agency website, the previous cards you’ve mailed, and how payment works. Explain that you’ll send the mail date and the proof of mailing, and that they can see their ad and results in their own workspace.
Follow up, every time
Most spots aren’t sold on the first conversation. Write down each objection, answer it, and follow up on a date you choose. In 9x12 CRM, each lead keeps its status, notes and next step, and you can turn on automatic follow-up emails for a lead so nobody falls through the cracks. Our guide to selling ad spots covers the outreach itself.
Frequently Asked Questions
What’s the most common objection to postcard advertising? Price. Answer it by showing what one customer is worth to the business and how few the card needs to bring in, or offer a smaller spot.
How do I answer “does direct mail still work”? Talk about measurement rather than statistics: every ad gets its own QR code and offer, so the advertiser sees what their spot did.
Should I offer discounts to close a sale? Prefer a smaller spot or a multi-campaign discount over cutting your price for one card. Discounts for committing to several campaigns reward the behavior you want.
How many times should I follow up? Two or three follow-ups over a couple of weeks is reasonable, with a real reason each time, such as the booking deadline or the last spots left.
Can I guarantee results to win a sale? No. Promise what you control: the homes reached, the mail date, the design and the tracking.
→ Track every lead and follow-up on 9x12 CRM, free to start. More guides from 9x12 Agency CRM.
Next read: best industries for postcard advertising · how to get advertisers to rebook